Philippines staffing guide · Published
Write a vendor reference check script for an outsourced recruitment desk
A reference call produces useful evidence only when every candidate is asked the same questions and the answers are recorded the same way. The recruitment desk needs a script that separates facts from impressions.

The short answer
A reference check is evidence gathering, not a character conversation. Use the same questions, record what the reference actually observed, and keep impressions separate from facts. The desk can summarize the evidence, but the hiring manager should make the final judgment.
Confirm the candidate and the relationship
Before the call, confirm the candidate's full name, the role being filled, and the reference's relationship to the candidate. Ask how long they worked together and in what capacity. A reference who only knew the candidate socially cannot speak to the work.
Ask for the spelling of the name if it is unclear. Record the dates and the reporting line so the hiring manager can weigh the answer.
Explain the purpose of the call and how the notes will be used. Ask permission to take notes and to share a summary with the hiring manager. If the reference asks not to be quoted, record that preference and summarize without attribution.
A short introduction protects the reference and keeps the conversation focused on job-related evidence. Keep the introduction under a minute.
Ask the same questions in the same order
Use a fixed question set for every candidate so the answers can be compared. Start with the scope of the role, then ask for one example of strong work and one example of a problem the candidate handled.
Follow with questions about reliability, communication, and the level of supervision required. Keep the order stable, because the sequence shapes how much detail a reference offers.
Avoid leading questions that suggest the answer you want. Ask what the candidate did, not whether the candidate was great. When a reference gives a general phrase, ask for a specific situation and the result.
A script is not a rigid interrogation; it is a way to make sure every candidate gets the same chance to produce evidence. A neutral question produces a more useful answer.
Separate observed facts from impressions
Write the reference's words close to verbatim when they describe an event. Put opinions in a separate column and label them as impressions. This distinction matters when two references disagree, because a fact can be checked while an impression can only be weighed.
The hiring manager should see which parts of the summary are evidence and which are interpretation. Quote the short phrase rather than a long paragraph.
Do not soften a negative answer into a neutral one, and do not turn a vague compliment into a strong endorsement. Record hesitations, refusals, and changes of subject as part of the answer. A reference who declines to discuss performance may be telling you something important.
Neutral wording can hide a real warning. The note should preserve that signal without guessing at its cause.
Score the answers against the role
Build a small scorecard from the requirements that matter most in the role. Use the same criteria for every candidate and define what a strong, mixed, and weak answer looks like. Score only after the call, using the notes rather than memory.
Write the criteria before the first call so the role, not the candidate, sets the standard. The score should summarize the evidence, not replace it.
Keep the scoring simple enough that a hiring manager can read it in a minute. Three to five criteria are usually enough for a support or administrative role.
If a criterion has no evidence from any reference, mark it unverified rather than giving it a middle score. An unverified requirement is a gap in the process, not a neutral result.
Escalate discrepancies before an offer
Compare the reference answers with the candidate's own account of the same role. A difference in dates or responsibilities may be a memory issue, but a difference in the reason for leaving deserves a question. Ask the candidate before the hiring manager forms a view.
Ask the candidate for context before treating the discrepancy as a problem. Record both accounts and who resolved the difference.
Send the hiring manager a short summary that names the strongest evidence and the largest open question. Do not bury a serious concern in a long narrative. If the reference raised a safety, integrity, or customer-harm issue, route it to the client owner before any offer is discussed.
Keep the summary to one page. The desk should not decide whether the concern is disqualifying.
Keep the reference record defensible
Store the notes, the question set, and the summary in one file linked to the candidate. Limit access to the hiring team and follow the client's retention rule.
Do not keep reference notes in a personal notebook or a chat thread that disappears when the project ends. A hiring decision may be questioned months later, and the record is the only reliable account.
Follow the client's policy on background checks and protected information. Reference calls can touch on health, family, or other personal topics that should not influence the hiring decision. If a reference volunteers that kind of information, redirect the conversation to the work.
Ask the client which topics are off limits before the call. Note that the topic was raised but keep it out of the scorecard.
Review the reference file with the hiring manager before the offer is approved. Check that every criterion has an answer or is marked unverified. Confirm that the notes do not contain unrelated personal information.
If the file is incomplete, do not fill the gap with a guess. Send it back to the desk for a follow-up call or a written note that names the missing evidence, and keep the completed file for the period the client requires.
Questions to copy for the sales call
- "How long did you work with the candidate, and in what role?"
- "What was the candidate responsible for day to day?"
- "Tell me about one piece of work the candidate did well."
- "What kind of supervision did the candidate need?"
- "Would you hire the candidate again for a similar role, and why?"
Sources
- EEOC: Background checks: Federal guidance on employment background checks and consistent treatment of candidates.
- SBA: Hire and manage employees: Small-business guidance on hiring steps, documentation, and employee management.
- O*NET OnLine: Role descriptions and work activities that help define reference-check criteria.
Common questions
How many references should the desk call?
Follow the client's policy, usually two or three work references. At least one should have managed the candidate directly.
Can the desk ask why the candidate left?
Yes, if the question is job-related and asked consistently. Record the answer and compare it with what the candidate said.
What if a reference will not answer a question?
Record the refusal without pressure, note the question that was declined, and continue with the rest of the script.
Should the desk share the notes with the candidate?
Follow the client's policy. A summary may be appropriate, but raw notes and the reference's identity should be handled with care.